Eggs are not bad for your heart, thirty-year study finds


© Getty Images
Researchers say eating up to one egg every day is not associated with an increased risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) – which can lead to heart attack or stroke.

Eggs will not increase your heart disease or stroke risk as previously feared, a thirty-year study has found.

Because of their cholesterol content, eggs have long been the subject of fierce debate around their role in causing heart problems.

But scientists say they have finally cracked the case – confirming that there is no link.

A US team, headed by a Harvard researcher, measured the diets of 215,618 healthy men and women who averaged one to five eggs a week for 32 years.

They found no association between egg intake and risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) – which can lead to heart attack or stroke.

The findings, published in The British Medical Journal, did find that people who ate more than one egg a day had a higher risk, but they also tended to eat more red meat and have a higher body mass index.

Study author Dr Jean-Philippe Drouin-Chartier said: ‘The association between egg consumption and cardiovascular disease risk has been a topic of intense debate during the past decade.

‘Findings from previous studies on egg consumption and risk of cardiovascular disease have been inconclusive.

‘The results from our cohort study and updated meta analysis show that moderate egg consumption (up to one egg per day) is not associated with cardiovascular disease risk overall.

‘Results were similar for coronary heart disease and stroke.’

The American study participants included 83,349 female nurses aged 30 to 55, 90,214 female nurses aged 25 to 44 and 42,055 male health professionals aged 40 to 75.

All were were free of CVD, type 2 diabetes and cancer at the start of the study.

When scientists checked in with their cohort a while later, there were 14,806 cases of CVD, including 9,010 cases of coronary heart disease and 5,903 cases of stroke.

Most people ate between one to five eggs per week, and those with a higher egg intake had a higher BMI, were less likely to be treated with statins – cholesterol lowering medication – and ate more red meat.

But there was no link between egg consumption and CVD risk after adjusting for age, lifestyle and dietary factors.

Participants were more at risk of CVD when researchers replaced one whole egg a day with a serving of processed red meat (15 per cent), unprocessed meat (10 per cent) or full fat milk (11 per cent).

Foods such as fish, poultry, legumes, cheese and nuts in place of eggs were not linked to CVD risk.

The experts advised eggs are an affordable source of high-quality protein, iron and unsaturated fatty acids.

Professor Andrew Odegaard, at the University of California, said the results of the study are convincing – but ‘we should not put all our eggs in this observational basket for formal guidance on eating eggs’.

He said: ‘If frequent egg consumption is occurring in the context of an overall dietary pattern known to be cardioprotective, or eggs are being consumed for essential nutritional needs, then it is probably nothing to worry about.

‘Single foods could have contextual relevance for health, but a complex and extensive body of nutrition and dietary research really does support the current focus on overall dietary patterns in recommendations and guidelines.’

Dietitian Dr Carrie Ruxton commented on the findings, saying: ‘The debate about eggs and cholesterol has continued for years, despite public bodies in the UK and elsewhere saying time and again that eating eggs doesn’t present a risk to blood cholesterol levels or cardiovascular risk.’

‘This study is a helpful addition to our knowledge because it confirms that eating seven eggs a week is not linked to heart disease or stroke. It also backs up evidence from intervention trials which show no impact of egg consumption on blood cholesterol levels.

‘Given that eggs are rich in protein and nutrient-dense, providing one of the few dietary sources of vitamin D, it’s great that we can put people’s minds to rest’.

Lead researcher Dr Dominik Alexander, of the EpidStat Institute, US, said more research is needed to understand the connection between egg consumption and stroke risk.

But he added: ‘Eggs do have many positive nutritional attributes, including antioxidants, which have been shown to reduce oxidative stress and inflammation.

‘They are also an excellent source of protein, which has been related to lower blood pressure.’

The researchers added that their observational study could not say with certainty whether it was the eggs or meat or something else that caused the increase.

A previous study found that consuming just one egg a day reduces the risk of stroke by 12 percent.

And results from an updated meta-analysis of 28 observational studies with more than 1.7million participants further supports the lack of an association between egg intake and CVD risk.

But evidence did vary between studies conducted in the US, Europe and Asia.

There was no link between egg consumption and CVD risk among US and European studies, but moderate egg consumption was associated with a slightly lower CVD risk in Asian populations.

Researchers said this may be due to eggs being included in a variety of Asian dishes while eggs tend to be eaten with red and processed meat in western populations.

CVD, a general term for conditions affecting the heart or blood vessels, is one of the main causes of death and disability in the UK.